Oct 4 / Jon Collier

Are You Quitting Your Church, or Just Comparing a Version You See Online?

It's Sunday morning. The worship set is fine. The sound guy missed a cue again. The announcements run long, and the pastor's sermon has a slide with a typo in it. And somewhere between the second song and the offering, you start writing a resignation letter in your head.

You'd never say it out loud. You're still smiling at the greeter. You still put your kid in the classroom. But inside, you're already halfway out the door.

Can I gently say something? Is it that your church really isn't for you anymore, or are you just impressed by the online version of that other church?

The Scroll

It usually doesn't start on Sunday. It starts on a Tuesday night, on the couch, phone in hand.

You open the app for one thing and end up on another church's page. Their worship team looks like they walked out of a music video. The lighting is perfect. The kids' wing has a slide. The youth group just got back from a trip that looks like a summer camp brochure. There's a reel of their pastor that has more views than your church has members.

You keep scrolling. Another church. A new building. A packed room. Hands raised in the haze.

And then you look up from your phone and think about your own church. The folding chairs. The same three songs. The leak in the fellowship hall nobody's fixed. The small group that's been "taking a break" since spring.

You feel a little smaller. You feel a little embarrassed for feeling it. So you put the phone down and pretend you didn't notice.

But you did. And on Sunday, it comes with you.

scroll down to read more »

Write your awesome label here.

Church Experience Assessment

Take our free church experience assessment, Unquittable Pulse, and put words to what you have been feeling. This will be helpful in guiding you to the resources that bring healing, rest, and purpose.

What Comparison Is Really Saying

Here's the hard part, and I say it with grace because I've felt it too. Comparison isn't just a mood. Underneath it is a quiet kind of unbelief. It's the assumption that God got your portion wrong. That He put you in the wrong room with the wrong people, and that real life with Jesus is happening somewhere else.

Paul gives us a better way to live. He writes:

"Pay careful attention to your own work, for then you will get the satisfaction of a job well done, and you won't need to compare yourself to anyone else." (Galatians 6:4, NLT)


Notice what he doesn't say. He doesn't say your work doesn't matter. He doesn't say ignore what's broken. He says pay careful attention to your own work. Look at what's actually in front of you. The people God actually gave you. The place where your hands can actually do something.

Comparison keeps your eyes on someone else's highlight reel. Faithfulness keeps your eyes on your own field. One leaves you empty. The other, Paul says, leaves you with the satisfaction of a job well done.

scroll down to read more »

An Honest Word

Now, let me be careful here, because I don't want this to turn into one more guilt trip.

Sometimes the itch is real. Sometimes your church genuinely needs to change. Maybe nobody listens. Maybe people are burning out and leadership won't slow down. Maybe there's no room for anyone to use their gifts. Maybe it's worse than that, and you're not safe. Those aren't comparison problems, and you don't have to pretend they are.

So don't shame the question. Ask it honestly. Is what's pulling me away about health, or about polish? Am I leaving because something is wrong, or because something somewhere else looks shinier? Would I still want to go if I'd never seen their feed?

Here's what's worth remembering while you sort that out. Nobody's livestream is the real church. The real church is the one where you know the names of the people who hurt you, and you still show up. It's where somebody brought you a meal when you were sick. It's where the coffee is weak and the prayers are honest. It's where you've seen people at their worst, and they've seen you at yours, and you're still in the same room.

That's not a lesser version of church. That might be the most real version there is.

The church you see online is a set of moments someone chose to post. The church you sit in every Sunday is a set of people God chose to put next to you. One of those you can scroll past. The other one is your family.

scroll down to read more »

Write your awesome label here.

Becoming Unquittable Workshop

A self-paced workshop that walks you through the 6 Unquittable Actions with teaching, reflection, and practical steps.

Perfect if you want guided support as you process what you’ve experienced.

A Question to Sit With

Before you finish that resignation letter in your head, take a few quiet minutes with this:

If you took away everything you've seen online, what would you honestly say is right about your church, and what would you honestly say is wrong?

Write down both lists. Then ask Jesus which one He wants you to pay careful attention to first.

You might still decide it's time to go. Or you might find that the church you were about to quit is the one where God has been quietly growing you all along.

scroll down to read more »

Write your awesome label here.

Becoming Unquittable: 

Finding Hope When You're Broken, Burnt Out, & Bored of the Church

Whether you’re considering leaving your church or have already walked away, this book will help you find the hope, healing, and purpose you’ve been searching for.

Share This With Someone

You’ve been showing up, but something feels off

Maybe you’re angry. rebellious or

You’re just tired, hurt, or quietly drifting from church.

Created with